Single song matching by acoustid should only use recording with most sources

Description

> What made me a little bit wonder, why Jaikoz 8.2.4 matches "Natalie La Rose feat. Jeremih - Somebody" with MB recording id f7629592-96df-4a35-8820-dd712837fc97 and MB release ID a03cb4f4-7239-4f25-8c15-46a869a3196b to "Jefferson Airplane - Somebody to Love" (acoustid bb44f64d-8a93-43ff-b4a0-71312735b7ca)
>
Its not clear - it may have something to do with the fact that acoustid also links to https://musicbrainz.org/recording/e0819d55-c506-4228-bd05-b077fec945a8, and maybe one of the albums that is linked to contains the Jefferson Airplane song, and because both songs contain 'Somebody' in the title it gets through. Ive added some more debugging into the Jaikoz version im building for you

Paul

Activity

Show:
Paul Taylor
July 6, 2015, 11:32 AM

This acoustid links to a Dusty Springfield song as well. The 1st stage of acoustid matching is to return a list of releases containing for each of the matching tracks, now because there are so many releases linked to the Dusty Springfield release we dont check all the releases there are too many, the Dusty ones are conincidentally returned first and when we check the song against each release we find another song that gives a good track match based on title and track length (by jeffreson Areoplane) so we use that

Single song matching by acoustid should only use recording with most sources when there are too many matches to imprve the chances of checking against the most likely match

Paul Taylor
July 6, 2015, 11:34 AM

Fixed.

Fixed

Reporter

Paul Taylor

Labels

None

Forum Username

alfg

os

None

Fix versions

Affects versions

Priority

Blocker
Configure